Showing posts with label JPMorgan Chase. Show all posts
Showing posts with label JPMorgan Chase. Show all posts

Thursday, May 17, 2012

Comments on JPMorgan's billions and the GDP


JPMorgan (and big banks in general)

Should a bank that is too big to fail be allowed to fail?

Ten years ago we wouldn't be having this conversation.  We should have been having it then, but we weren't.  My recollection is that such a question entered the popular consciousness only during the dark days of the financial crisis of 2008.

That question is actually a shorthand for a longer and more complete question; in its greater form, the question is this:  Should a bank that is too big to fail without its failure having catastrophic consequences for the overall economy be allowed to fail?

That's a good question, but I think there's a better one.

Nothing is too big to fail.  Even the biggest and strongest of the giant Sequoia trees in California's Sierra Nevada mountains will eventually be struck by lightning or some other calamity and come toppling down.
                     


These big trees have been around for centuries.  As they become really old and really big, their vulnerabilities pile up.  Eventually, something brings them down.  Others in the immediate vicinity become collateral damage and get knocked down, too, but it doesn't become a catastrophic event for the entire forest.

The comment

Confused in the Great Midwest has commented on my May 14 posting on JPMorgan's recent multi-billion dollar mistake in derivatives trading by raising the "too big to fail" question.  CITGM's comment is worth reading in full, but here's the closing point:  "Perhaps we need to challenge the notion of 'too big to fail.'  . . .  It's not yet a crime to make a bad bet. But let's also let them bear the full consequences of their decisions. The next time a mega-bank becomes insolvent as a result of poor decision-making, let's let them fail."

Those are reasonable points, and there's no denying the seductive simplicity in letting nature take its course; in making it so that people--or organizations--bear the consequences of their decisions; in recognizing the wages of sin; and then letting life continue.


Now that you've mentioned it. . .

Unfortunately, JPMorgan, and all the other big banks--all of which can fail--are big enough that any such failures would probably topple the country into a financial depression.  Collateral damage is not a pretty sight.  The failure of a big bank would create a big, ugly mess.  Lehman Brothers and Bear Stearns were not anywhere near as large as the big banks of today are, but they fell over in 2008 and we are still feeling the effects of that financial crushing.

So, yes, let's challenge the notion of "too big to fail."  I agree.

This is the question that ought to be asked:  Do we need banks that are as big as these guys have become? 

If so, then let's recognize the fact that we are allowing ourselves to be placed into a national financial environment that we have never been in before--at least, not in almost a century--and then ask this follow-on question:  What national coping mechanism is needed to enable us to exist in a secure, prosperous and democratic way when the great majority of financial power is concentrated in fewer people and organizations than at any time since the 1920s, or perhaps not since the days of the so-called Robber Barons of the late 19th and early 20th centuries?

On the flip-side, if we don't really need banks to be so big, then how do we make them smaller so that if one of them makes a bad bet and it fails, then life goes on, at least for everybody else?

The amount of financial concentration in this country is not generally appreciated.  Two days ago on May 15, Argus Market Watch reported:  "Despite the fact that there are still more than 8,000 chartered banks in the
U.S., a staggering 80% of all bank assets are held by a relative small handful of banks with greater than $10 billion of assets. Thirty years ago, that percentage was closer to 20%."  (The emphasis is mine.)

That's an earth-shaking change in the financial landscape, and the Dodd-Frank Act is the first, and only, major piece of national law-making that has been accomplished to try to update America's legal environment to address the tectonic shifts in its banking and business financial environment.

I don't know if we need mega-banks like JPMorgan, Bank of America, Citi and Wells Fargo.  But as a nation we have encouraged them to exist and to get bigger--the repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act set the foundations for today's banking system, and the banking consolidations of the last several years have built higher and higher on that foundation.  Now we have to address the consequences by either accepting the status quo and learning how to live with it--which is what the Dodd-Frank Act does--or by changing things and breaking up the big banks.


GDP and growth

Anonymous asked this question about the April 27 posting on GDP:  "Do you really need to have a GDP that is growing or could you have a flat GDP and still have a healthy economy?"

Good question, if somewhat unexpected because we focus so much of our attention on growth.

GDP should grow at least as fast as the country's population growth.  That way, the average prosperity--when measured as GDP per capita--will at least stay on an even keel.  If GDP grows at a slower rate than does the population, then there is less prosperity per person.  I would call the first scenario "healthy" and the second scenario "unhealthy."  Since the population of the United States is growing, and will continue to grow for the foreseeable future, then GDP needs to grow by at least the same rate in order for us to have a healthy economy.



Monday, May 14, 2012

JPMorgan's billions

These big bank folks don't have much fondness for government regulation of their business, but they sure make a good case for it.  Likewise, they are making a good case for voting Democratic in the November elections.

All of this is because of last week's news about the big bank JPMorgan Chase losing at least $2 billion in doing some bad trading in financial instruments called derivatives.  That's a whole lot of money.  Maybe it's not life-threatening for a bank as big as JPMorgan, but it was only about four or five years ago that similar things were said about the big financial companies Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers, and we all know how things turned out for them, and consequently for the whole world's financial system, our nation's economy and several million American jobs:  pretty darned badly.

Simple math at JPMorgan = simple politics

Here's more perspective:  JPMorgan's CEO, a fellow named Jamie Diamon, has been quoted as grousing about the Dodd-Frank financial legislation because it will cost JPMorgan so much money to implement the new guidelines and to prepare for the regulatory oversight.  How much does he think it will cost?  Well, maybe something like $400 million to $500 million.  And yet they can drop four or five times that much in a single trade, and accept it as an affordable cost of doing business.

The math seems pretty simple to me:  if the nation's biggest bank can afford the cost of a single bad trade, then it can afford the cost of prudent oversight that is only a fraction of the cost of that bad trade.  That's true for all the other big banks, too.

The politics of this also seem pretty simple to me:  President Obama and the Democrats, in general, are the horses to ride in the November elections because they are the ones who are committed to implementing and using the financial oversight of the Dodd-Frank legislation.  The Republican challengers in this election are mistaken when they call for the repeal of Dodd-Frank and say that things are better when the big banks are allowed to oversee their operations without government involvement.  That's like saying the fox will be a great guardian in the hen-house.

Don't like Dodd-Frank?  Try remembering Bear-Lehman

Today's Republican Party is guilty of indulging in the same logic that helped Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers to end up the way that they did.  And they took the rest us us along for a very bumpy ride.  We don't want another ride like that one.

Here's the eagle

Officially named the Dodd–Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act and accompanied by the mighty fine-looking Great Seal of the United States Great Seal of the United States.this hefty piece of legislation introduces itself with this goal statement:

"An Act to promote the financial stability of the United States by improving accountability and transparency in the financial system, to end "too big to fail", to protect the American taxpayer by ending bailouts, to protect consumers from abusive financial services practices, and for other purposes."

My guess is that somewhere in the Act's 848 pages there are things to be found that are imperfect and will need some modifications to deliver on the goal.  That's not unusual.  This is complicated stuff.  Mostly, though, it's got us going in the right direction to fix some very big problems.

Big banks, big deals, big money. . .big problems

Does anybody really understand everything that the big banks do these days?  Does anybody fully understand financial derivatives, collateralized debt obligations, mortgage-backed securities, and things whose names are beyond the everyday knowledge of at least 99% of the population but which are worth millions or billions of dollars as the banks trade them daily?  I don't.  But some people do.

Apparently, though, a few employees at one of the most accomplished and savvy banks in the world thought they knew more than they did, and so the end result of their recklessness is billions in red ink.

Perhaps there was nothing illegal about what went on at JPMorgan.  Maybe this is some kind of mole-hill that looks like a mountain right now, and the view might change in a few weeks.  There's no way of knowing what will turn up as the facts are brought to light.  As I am writing this, we are still in the dark on most of the facts of this case.

But for now, at least, it evokes bad memories of other really, really smart people having way too much fun playing with lots and lots of other people's money a few years ago.

Here's the evidence, so here's my vote

Government regulation and regulators are far from perfect, but I think it's time that we learn from the mistakes of our recent past, and accept the fact that the big banks will not regulate and oversee themselves.  They have no systemic motivation to do it, and even if they did have the motivation, they still don't know how to do it.  Instead, when let loose to play without enough adult supervision, they revert to their former bad habits.  The evidence for that just keeps on piling up.

It's the same evidence that says that President Obama and the Democrats in Congress are on the right track with their overhaul of financial regulation.

They have my vote to stay on the same track.